AddiWire

Additive manufacturing news and European prices, with independent expert commentary

Materials

TANIOBIS transfers niobium alloy parameters to a four-laser printer, nozzles come out crack-free

Published 1 sourceSummary written with AIDeutsche Version

Powder producer TANIOBIS has shown that the niobium alloys C-103 and FS-85 can be processed by laser powder bed fusion on an industrial four-laser machine. Settings developed on a single-laser system carried over with small changes, and demonstrator rocket nozzles were built without cracks. The researchers see no technical barrier left to series production, with qualification as the remaining step.

Key facts
  • Settings moved from single-laser AM400 to four-laser AM500Q with minor changes
  • 52 test cubes stayed below 0.3% porosity across the plate
  • FS-85 kept about 220 MPa tensile strength at 1,500 °C
  • Elmet Technologies to distribute both powders in North America

Context C-103 and FS-85 are niobium alloys; niobium is a refractory metal with a melting point of 2,477 °C, useful where nickel superalloys begin to soften, above about 1,050 °C.

Moving a parameter set from one laser to four with small corrections is the valuable part of this work, because the overlap zones between lasers are a common source of variation. I take the claim that nothing technical blocks series production in a narrow sense: it covers the process, not any particular part. The strength figures come from bars and cubes, and as-built niobium behaves differently along and across the build axis, so a nozzle's properties depend on its orientation and heat treatment. Before a European space or hypersonics programme commits, I would ask a supplier for four things: specimens cut from an actual nozzle, oxygen content after repeated powder reuse, creep and thermal cycling data rather than short tensile tests alone, and the exact heat treatment behind every number. Cutting up a few nozzles for testing hurts at that powder price. It still costs less than finding the anisotropy in a flight article.
Commentary by Svetozar Kolesar

What did TANIOBIS demonstrate on the four-laser machine?

Parameters first developed on a single-laser AM400 moved to a four-laser AM500Q with only minor adjustments. Parts showed porosity under 0.1% and density above 99.9%. To test consistency, the team spread 52 cubes randomly over the plate using the four best parameter sets, and porosity stayed below 0.3% everywhere, apart from a few outliers likely caused by spatter.

Nozzles of 53 mm diameter and 100 mm height followed, without visible defects. Early builds used one laser to prove reproducibility, later ones used all four at once to raise throughput. The C-103 process window widened on the AM500Q to 95 to 255 J/mm³.

How do the two alloys compare in strength and heat?

FS-85 is the stronger grade at room temperature, about 750 MPa tensile strength against 565 MPa for C-103, and it is stiffer. C-103 is the more ductile one, stretching 20 to 22% before fracture against 6 to 7% for FS-85. Heat treatment can raise elongation of both to about 30% with little strength loss.

At high temperature FS-85 led across the tested range up to 1,600 °C: at 1,500 °C it still carried roughly 220 MPa tensile strength while C-103 had almost none left. Printed C-103 was clearly stronger than rolled C-103 (557 against 420 MPa tensile), though the gap narrowed above about 800 °C. As-built grains are elongated along the build axis, so properties depend on direction.

Powder, parameters and the wider qualification effort

The powder came from EIGA atomization, sieved to 15 to 63 µm, with near-spherical particles. On the AM400, C-103 tolerated 160 to 240 J/mm³ while FS-85 needed a narrower 105 to 125 J/mm³. Tuning cut porosity from about 1% to 0.06%.

TANIOBIS has signed Elmet Technologies to distribute both powders in North America. Elsewhere, Elmet installed a 3D Systems DMP Flex 350 Triple with tight oxygen control, Velo3D is qualifying Amaero's C103 powder, and America Makes and NCDMM awarded $6 million for refractory alloy work. C103 powder can cost up to $4,000 per kg.

What it means

For European manufacturers in space and hypersonics, the result moves niobium from a lab topic towards a multi-laser production route, but powder at up to $4,000 per kg and tight oxygen control keep entry costly. The practical hurdle is qualification: direction-dependent properties, reduced ductility versus rolled stock and a still thin public dataset mean flight use needs part-level testing. Small firms are more likely to buy such parts from specialist bureaus than to run these systems themselves.

Frequently asked questions

Which niobium alloys did TANIOBIS print?

C-103 and FS-85, processed by laser powder bed fusion on an AM400 and an AM500Q four-laser system.

Which alloy performs better at very high temperature?

FS-85. At 1,500 °C it still held about 220 MPa tensile strength, while C-103 had almost no strength left.

What still stands in the way of series production?

According to the report, qualification rather than printability: consistent property data, process variability and supply chains still need work.

Read the original reports
  1. 3D Printing Industry, 11 Nov 2026