The case for caution came from Arno Held. In his view, much of today's AM growth rests on defence. That demand is set by government budgets rather than by natural market need, and budgets can change quickly. He also noted that the hype money has dried up, the market has too many players, and consolidation is overdue.

Rainer Lotz saw it differently. For him, defence is an accelerator, not the foundation. It filled the gap left by a weaker automotive sector. Underneath, he pointed to steady growth in consumer electronics, energy, medical, and anywhere heat management is the problem, including cooling for AI servers. He described metal AM as stabilised and scaling, with flexibility and automation as its main strengths.

Mahdi Jamshid put the market growth at around 10.5 percent and described three distinct markets: Asia, Europe and the USA, with China pushing for self reliance by 2030. His prescription was structural. The industry needs a large player that owns the whole chain from start to finish, able to supply the market and use available incentives.

Dr. Markus Heering focused on Europe. The continent remains fragmented, with each country running its own defence budget. Production has to speed up, and companies have to work together. He added that OEMs want collaboration, while multimaterial processes are not yet ready for scale.

Ross Trepleton, whose MTC gathers industry requirements and looks for solutions, saw AI as a chance to accelerate the industry and connect its parts.

Infographic comparing panel views: defence as the foundation of AM growth versus defence as an accelerator, plus key points from Wohlers, VDMA and MTC.
Where the panel agreed and where it split.

Why it matters

Both readings can be true at once. Defence is pulling volume forward today, but the companies that last will be the ones whose applications pay off without a defence contract. For buyers, the question is not whether AM is growing, but whether a specific part makes sense on its own merits.

AddiWire is covering Formnext 2026 all week from Frankfurt.